Mobile Site You Are Here >  >  > NHL Elo Player Rater: Duncan Keith vs. Tony Tanti

NHL Elo Player Rater

This is a community-based project with the goal of rating the best players in NHL history. In the matchup below, choose the player who you believe was the better player. It is up to you to determine how much weight to give to offense versus defense, peak value versus career value, regular season versus playoffs, etc.

Current Top Five (Skaters):
1. Bobby Orr (2279)
2. Wayne Gretzky (2272)
3. Mario Lemieux (2248)
4. Raymond Bourque (2183)
5. Jaromir Jagr (2171)
Current Top Five (Goalies):
1. Patrick Roy (2047)
2. Terry Sawchuk (2036)
3. Dominik Hasek (2024)
4. Jacques Plante (2015)
5. Martin Brodeur (1979)

» Read the fine details or view the complete ratings.

Who's Better: or ? Skip

  Tale of the Tape
  Duncan Keith Tony Tanti
Pos D RW
Height 6-1 5-9
Weight 200 180
Draft 2002 (54th) 1981 (12th)
Debut 2005-06 1981-82
Years 10 11
AS Game 2 1
AS Team 2 (2/0) 0
Hart 0 0
Norris 2 0
Selke 0 0
Vezina 0 0
Cups 2 0
HoF No No
Adjusted Point Shares*
(Best → Worst)
Rk Duncan Keith Tony Tanti
1 12.6 7.6
2 10.0 7.2
3 9.4 7.2
4 9.4 6.0
5 8.7 4.9
6 7.2 4.6
7 7.1 3.5
8 5.6 1.8
9 4.1 1.1
10 1.0 0.7
11 -0.1
Wt Sum** 62.5 38.0

* Adjusted for schedule length & roster size
** 1 × best + 0.95 × 2nd-best + …

  Regular Season
  Duncan Keith Tony Tanti
GP 692 697
G 67 287
A 307 273
PTS 374 560
+/- 125 -67
PIM 449 661
 Goals
EV 46 167
PP 16 118
SH 5 2
GW 7 29
 Shots
S 1431 1831
 
S% 4.7 15.7
 Per Game
G 0.10 0.41
A 0.44 0.39
PTS 0.54 0.80
GC 0.17 0.34
+/- 0.18 -0.10
PIM 0.65 0.95
S 2.07 2.63
 Adjusted
G 104 234
A 371 226
PTS 475 460
GC 158 189
 Point Shares
OPS 27.2 35.1
DPS 43.9 8.4
PS 71.2 43.5

123 ≡ incomplete data

  Playoffs
  Duncan Keith Tony Tanti
GP 93 30
G 12 3
A 42 12
PTS 54 15
+/- 18 -9
PIM 54 27
 Goals
EV 11 2
PP 1 1
SH 0 0
GW 2 0
 Shots
S 205 57
 
S% 5.9 5.3
 Per Game
G 0.13 0.10
A 0.45 0.40
PTS 0.58 0.50
GC 0.19 0.17
+/- 0.19 -0.35
PIM 0.58 0.90
S 2.20 2.19

123 ≡ incomplete data