Mobile Site You Are Here > > > NHL Elo Player Rater: Shorty Green vs. Lou Nanne

NHL Elo Player Rater

This is a community-based project with the goal of rating the best players in NHL history. In the matchup below, choose the player who you believe was the better player. It is up to you to determine how much weight to give to offense versus defense, peak value versus career value, regular season versus playoffs, etc.

Current Top Five (Skaters):
1. Bobby Orr (2277)
2. Wayne Gretzky (2259)
3. Gordie Howe (2239)
4. Mario Lemieux (2184)
5. Jean Beliveau (2063)
Current Top Five (Goalies):
1. Martin Brodeur (1975)
2. Patrick Roy (1940)
3. Dominik Hasek (1935)
4. Glenn Hall (1924)
5. Jacques Plante (1906)

» Read the fine details or view the complete ratings.

Who's Better: or ? Skip

  Tale of the Tape
  Shorty Green Lou Nanne
Pos RW D/RW
Height 5-10 6-1
Weight 152 185
Draft
Debut 1923-24 1967-68
Years 4 11
AS Game 0 0
AS Team 0 0
Hart 0 0
Norris 0 0
Selke 0 0
Vezina 0 0
Cups 0 0
HoF Yes No
Adjusted Point Shares*
(Best → Worst)
Rk Shorty Green Lou Nanne
1 7.6 4.4
2 3.2 4.1
3 1.7 3.9
4 0.0 2.8
5 2.7
6 2.3
7 1.5
8 0.2
9 0.1
10 -0.3
11 -1.3
Wt Sum** 12.2 18.5

* Adjusted for schedule length & roster size
** 1 × best + 0.95 × 2nd-best + …

  Regular Season
  Shorty Green Lou Nanne
GP 103 635
G 33 68
A 20 157
PTS 53 225
+/- -106
PIM 151 356
 Goals
EV 49
PP 18
SH 1
GW 10
 Shots on Goal
S 886
 
S% 7.7
 Per Game
G 0.32 0.11
A 0.19 0.25
PTS 0.51 0.35
GC 0.33 0.13
+/- -0.17
PIM 1.47 0.56
S 1.40
 Adjusted
G 58 64
A 122 150
PTS 180 214
GC 65 76
 Point Shares
OPS 6.5 4.2
DPS 2.4 17.0
PS 8.9 21.2

123 ≡ incomplete data

  Playoffs
  Shorty Green Lou Nanne
GP 32
G 4
A 10
PTS 14
+/-
PIM 8
 Goals
EV 4
PP 0
SH 0
GW 2
 Shots on Goal
S
 
S%
 Per Game
G 0.13
A 0.31
PTS 0.44
GC 0.15
+/-
PIM 0.25
S

123 ≡ incomplete data